CURRENT IN-STORE MENU

We rotate our pie menu each month!
For local Pick Up or Delivery, Pre-Order here
To ship a pie outside of the Los Angeles area, order here

Current In-Store Menu

Harvest Apple Pie™

Handmade by our very own Winston PieSmiths® this delicious Harvest Apple Pie™ is classic in every way. It has hand cut and peeled apples and just the right amount of cinnamon. Our apple pie is lightly sweetened, allowing the natural flavor of the season’s apples to shine through.

Available in All-Butter Original, Vegan, Gluten Free

Winter Berry Crumble (GFV)

Available in Full Size, mini and slices. GFV. Please note we are not a GF-certified bakery.

Carolina Classic Cherry Pie™

One of our top sellers! Our cherry pie is known around Los Angeles for the dark cherries in our flaky double crust. Our cherry pie isn’t super sweet but it is super delicious! Made with whole dark cherries and named after the Carolina Classic Fair!

Southern Pecan Pie™ (GF)

A true Southern tradition! Our Southern Pecan Pie™ has pecan throughout each bite. The gooey and nutty filling is paired with a flaky all-butter GF crust.

Chocolate Cowgirl Pie™

This chocolate chess pie is our twist on the Tarheel Pie. It has a rich chocolate filling using responsibly-sourced Ecuadorian chocolate in a salty oat crust. It is topped with a drizzle of handmade fresh caramel. Fudge-like texture with just the right amount of sweetness. If you are a chocohalic, this chocolate pie is for you!

Key West Lime Pie

This one is for the Key Lime lovers. Hand-squeezed limes and homemade graham cracker crust. This one is tart and creamy -it will get you in the back of your cheeks.

full size, minis and slices

Milky Way Pie!

Inspired by the classic candy bar. This new pie includes a handmade milk chocolate cookie crust, soft chocolate cream filling topped with a layer of salted handmade chewy caramel and finished with a smooth chocolate layer. Full Size and slices.

GF and v not available.

Coconut Dream (GF)

Coconut macaroon shells with a light coconut cream filling, a layer of dark chocolate topped with toasted coconut. Contains dairy. Comes in Full Size and slices. GF.

Bake at Home Apple Pie

PieBites and Hand Pies

PieBites - 2” bites and a Winston original! Hand pies are great for those who like a little more filling. Limited quantities baked each day - we recommend pre-ordering.

PAST FLAVORS

We love to recipe develop and we feature new flavors each month.

Looking to purchase a past favorite? Sign up for our newsletter and follow us on social media for all of the current in-store flavors!

Featured

Root Beer Float Pie

Our latest ice box pie inspired by the American classic Root Beer Float! Housemade cinnamon sugar cookie, creamy root beer filling topped with our handmade root beer toffee! This is one of a kind and a Winston original!

Strawberry Shortcake Pie

S'Mores Pie

Every August/September. Fresh chocolate pastry cream in a graham cracker crust and topped with housemade toasted marshmallow.

100 Grand Pie

Like the candy bar! Chocolate filling, dark caramel topped with puffed crispies.

Edna's Lemon Meringue

A limited-edition winter flavor. We use Meyer lemons for a sweet but tart filling. Housemade meringue!

Peach Blackberry Raspberry (PBR for short)

Summer 2020’s standout peach pie!

Passion Fruit Meringue

Babka Chocolate Swirl Pie

Inspired by Babka bread, this vanilla custard pie comes in a Nilla crust and features decorate chocolate swirls. New Fall of 2021 for the Jewish New Year!

Touchdown Pie

Homemade Oreo crust, fluffy peanut butter filling, a layer of chocolate and topped with pretzels. Served every Super Bowl Sunday.

Cookies 'n Cream

Housemade Oreo crust and cookie in a light creamy filling. Available in full size and slices.

Coconut Custard

Dulce de Leche Banana Cream

We feature a spin on banana cream pie multiple times a year and always for Father’s Day.

Strawberry Mascarpone Pie

A beautiful pie for Mother’s Day with fresh strawberries and edible flowers.

Coconut Macaroon Cream Pie

Featured every Easter and Passover. Coconut macaroon shell and fresh coconut pastry cream.

Pay Day Peanut Butter Pie

For April 15th Tax Day - Pay Day pie is inspired by the candy bar. Thick peanut butter filling, peanut butter cookie crust topped with rich handmade caramel on top.

Citrus Crostada

Winter citrus with a handmade marmalade. VGF

Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble

Sweet with some tang. We typically offer strawberry rhubarb pie starting in the late Spring.

Lemon Bar Pie (Sunshine Pie)

Inspired by the lemon bar! Portions of proceeds from this pie went to support social justice.

Boston Cream Pie

Sugar cookie crust, fresh pastry cream and a dark chocolate layer.

Dutch Apple Pie

Peach Blackberry Raspberry

A summer favorite featuring our favorite summer fruit! June-August

Peanut Butter Pie

Salted oat crust, creamy peanut butter and a chocolate filling. Inspired by our favor peanut butter cup candy.

Cookie Dough Pie

2022 started off with a BANG with this killer new candy bar pie! Chocolate chip cookie crust, light vanilla filling with big gobs of (eggless) cookie dough. It is amazing!

Southern Belle Red Velvet

Inspired by the Southern classic - this smooth chocolate pie has a cream cheese layer and chocolate shortbread crust. Valentine’s Day 2020.

Sweet Potato Pie

A Southern classic with a pecan crust.

Funfetti Sprinkle Pie

Funfetti! It is fun. It is SWEET. It has rainbow sprinkles! Sprinkle shortbread crust, vanilla mousse sprinkle filling. Topped with. . . sprinkles! Tastes like birthday cake batter.

Peach Bourbon Pie

Sweet yellow peaches with Southern bourbon. We start baking this beauty when peaches come into season late May -early June.

Caramel Twix Pie

Our twist on the Twix® candy bar. Homemade shortbread crust, chocolate ganache layer, with caramel filling. If you like pecan pie, check this one out too!

Mixed Berry Crumble (GFV)

Blackberries, raspberries, blueberries and boysenberries topped with an oat crumble. And it’s VGF!

Promisedland Pie (Milk & Honey)

Offered each year for the Jewish Holy Days. Creamy filling made with milk and honey topped with housemade honeycomb confection.

Featured

Spiced Pumpkin Pie with Spicy Pepitas

Winter Citrus Marmalade Hand Pies (GFV)

Whopper Pie

Malt chocolate cream filling!

Cranberry Apple Pie

Housemade cranberry compote with fresh harvest apples. As seen on The Hallmark Channel!

Thin Mint Pie

Chocolate crust with a fresh minty fluffy filling

Nutella Banana Cream

Homemade hazelnut chocolate spread with fresh bananas and vanilla pastry cream in a hazelnut cookie crust.

Strawberry Lemonade Pie

Lemony cream filling with strawberry swirls. Topped with housemade strawberry fruit roll up.